Old Ball Game Studios

The Series Nobody Won

A title both sides claimed, a bargain one side gave away, a rescue at the plate, and a handshake that kept the peace for a generation.

This Day in the Old Ball Game comic strip for October 24: four panels depicting the disputed 1885 championship series between the St. Louis Browns and Chicago White Stockings; the Cardinals selling José Cruz to the Astros in 1974; J.T. Snow scooping up three-year-old bat boy Darren Baker at home plate in Game 5 of the 2002 World Series; and owners and players announcing a new labor deal before Game 3 of the 2006 World Series.

Ed. 10.24.26

The Series Nobody Won (1885)

The St. Louis Browns crushed the Chicago White Stockings 13-4 in Cincinnati to close baseball's second championship series between rival leagues. Simple, right? Not quite. Back in Game 2, with angry St. Louis fans storming the field, the umpire retreated to his hotel and declared a Chicago forfeit. St. Louis claimed the title, Chicago called it a draw, and each owner finally just took back his own $500 stake.

The Bargain in Houston (1974)

José Cruz was a part-timer buried in a crowded St. Louis outfield. A year earlier he had even shared the Cardinals roster with his younger brothers Tommy and Héctor. On this day the Cardinals sold him to the Astros for cash. Cruz played the next 13 seasons in Houston, became a fan favorite, and in 1992 the Astros retired his No. 25.

A Rescue at the Plate (2002)

In Game 5 of the World Series, Kenny Lofton tripled, and three-year-old Giants bat boy Darren Baker, son of manager Dusty Baker, toddled out to fetch the bat. The play wasn't over. J.T. Snow, scoring with David Bell right behind him, grabbed Darren by the jacket and swept him out of the way. By January, MLB required bat boys to be at least 14. In 2024, Darren made his big league debut with the Nationals.

The Handshake (2006)

Baseball had suffered eight work stoppages from 1972 through 1995, including the strike that wiped out the 1994 World Series. So when owners and players announced a new five-year deal before Game 3 of the World Series, nearly two months before the old one expired, the news was that there was no drama at all. Labor peace held until a December 2021 lockout, more than 26 years after the last strike ended.

darren-bakerjose-cruz
Old Ball Game Studios · Season PassAdmit One · Daily

A Ticket to Every Morning of Baseball History

The daily strip, new Snapbacks, and stories from the stands — delivered like a ticket under your door. Free seat, forever.

YouTubeInstagramTikTokFacebookBox office opens soon — follow along meanwhile

Sec: History · Row: Front · Seat: Yours