Old Ball Game Studios

The Knickerbockers Put It in Writing

A gentlemen's rulebook, a run that never counted, an ace who joined the Navy three wins shy of 200, and a batter nobody let strike out.

This Day in the Old Ball Game comic strip for September 23: four panels depicting the Knickerbocker Base Ball Club adopting its written rules in 1845; Fred Merkle failing to touch second base against the Cubs in 1908; Larry French one-hitting the Phillies in his final start before joining the Navy in 1942; and Jim Deshaies striking out the first eight Dodgers he faced in 1986.

Ed. 09.23.26

The Knickerbockers Put It in Writing (1845)

On this day in New York, the Knickerbocker Base Ball Club adopted twenty written rules. The first side to 21 "aces" won, as long as both teams had batted an equal number of times. One rule banned a schoolyard favorite: retiring a runner by throwing the ball at him. Historians still argue over who actually wrote the rules. Nobody argues that the game got a lot less painful.

Fred Merkle Never Touches Second (1908)

Giants and Cubs, tied 1-1 in the bottom of the ninth at the Polo Grounds, pennant race dead even. With two outs and runners on the corners, Al Bridwell singled, the run crossed, and the crowd poured onto the field. Nineteen-year-old Fred Merkle, the runner from first, headed for the clubhouse without touching second. Johnny Evers got hold of a ball, stepped on the bag, and umpire Hank O'Day ruled Merkle out, with darkness forcing a tie. The Cubs won the replay, the pennant, and the World Series. They would not win another until 2016.

Larry French Goes Out on Top (1942)

In his final big league start, Brooklyn's Larry French one-hit the Phillies, 6-0, to finish a 15-4 season. That gave him 197 career wins. He joined the Navy that winter and hoped to keep pitching for the Dodgers. It never happened. French made the Navy his career, serving 27 years and retiring as a captain in 1969. The record book says 197. The Navy's says captain.

Jim Deshaies Starts With Eight (1986)

Astros rookie Jim Deshaies had not started in nearly two weeks. He came out firing at the Astrodome, striking out the first eight Dodgers he faced, a modern record nobody matched for 28 years. Next up was the pitcher's spot, and Tommy Lasorda had seen enough. He sent up pinch hitter Larry See, who popped out to second. Deshaies finished with a two-hit, 4-0 shutout and 10 strikeouts, eight of them before anyone put a ball in play.

fred-merklejim-deshaies
Old Ball Game Studios · Season PassAdmit One · Daily

A Ticket to Every Morning of Baseball History

The daily strip, new Snapbacks, and stories from the stands — delivered like a ticket under your door. Free seat, forever.

YouTubeInstagramTikTokFacebookBox office opens soon — follow along meanwhile

Sec: History · Row: Front · Seat: Yours